Category talk:Candidates for deletion: Difference between revisions
m (reformat) |
(My 3 cents on it.) |
||
| Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
::Why do you guys want to get rid of this stuff? The wiki and or game, needs stuff like this for noobs. What were you told if you needed to find something out? Go to the wiki, Ring Of Brodgar. Without the stuff like this for the early players, people will just quit the game, not knowing what to do. I think this stuff should be kept! --[[User:13579001]] 4:37 PM 7 October 2011 | ::Why do you guys want to get rid of this stuff? The wiki and or game, needs stuff like this for noobs. What were you told if you needed to find something out? Go to the wiki, Ring Of Brodgar. Without the stuff like this for the early players, people will just quit the game, not knowing what to do. I think this stuff should be kept! --[[User:13579001]] 4:37 PM 7 October 2011 | ||
:::(Apparently my other edit here bugged and didn't post, so here's what I basically said): I tagged that page for deletion since it doesn't fit in with what exactly the wiki is meant for. The wiki is meant for technical aspects of the game, like item info, building info, skill/stat info. It could potentially have a section on it in the [[kin]] page, but it isn't exactly necessary or right for it to have it's own page. This is the sort of thing which should be put into a guide or a How Do I thread, not the wiki. --[[User:ApocalypsePlease|Apocalypse Please]] 3:57, 8 October 2011 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 02:58, 8 October 2011
Please use this page to discuss pages that have been labelled for deletion.
Josan
As per my comment on the talk page - completely non-notable figure in the in-game community and the page does not accurately represent his contribution to the metagame community. Furthermore, deleting this page would set a precedent of not having pages about individual users on the wiki. (Do we need people trolling here, too?) -Winterbrass 10:56, March 15, 2010 (UTC)
List pages
I agree that the list pages should probably be deleted (at least those that are duplicated by category pages). Categories are more easily maintained.
I was investigating the possibility of eliminating the Skills list page when I ran across the delete suggestion on the Objects page. --SwordMage 21:43, March 28, 2010 (UTC)
I think Flax Crop should be deleted since any information about it should be found in Flax instead. Dataslycer 21:55, March 28, 2010 (UTC)
???
Delete of ??? page.
"Unsure this merits a wiki page"
- Its a general and literal in game used string. Although a '???' redirect to the kin page could do to. The '???' part could be made more prominent on the kin page though. See about moving/merging some of the data on the '???' page if warranted. And then clear it. (Don't know if it can be directly converted to a redirect page. After moving/clearing the data on the '???' page.) --MvGulik 18:18, 7 October 2011 (CDT)
- Why do you guys want to get rid of this stuff? The wiki and or game, needs stuff like this for noobs. What were you told if you needed to find something out? Go to the wiki, Ring Of Brodgar. Without the stuff like this for the early players, people will just quit the game, not knowing what to do. I think this stuff should be kept! --User:13579001 4:37 PM 7 October 2011
- (Apparently my other edit here bugged and didn't post, so here's what I basically said): I tagged that page for deletion since it doesn't fit in with what exactly the wiki is meant for. The wiki is meant for technical aspects of the game, like item info, building info, skill/stat info. It could potentially have a section on it in the kin page, but it isn't exactly necessary or right for it to have it's own page. This is the sort of thing which should be put into a guide or a How Do I thread, not the wiki. --Apocalypse Please 3:57, 8 October 2011 (UTC)