Talk:A Talking Whale

Fish or no fish (classification)

So it looks like a fish with a matching fishy name. (Technically a whale is of course a mammals.)

The main argument here would be that, just like the other game-fish items, it can 'only' be acquired by fishing. But that's also true for the An Old Boot & The Other Old Boot curiosities.

Also unlike the other fish it can't be eaten or further processed (as far as I know). As its just a curiosity, although very rare and therefor also a bit special.

Hmm, ... yea. I'm totally in favor of ditching the fish classification on the talking whale.

--.MvGulik. 17:05, 22 November 2025 (UTC)