User talk:Malyglut

hearth magics category icon list

The added of the list of hearth magics with their icons in the hearth magics category is not really adding anything substantial to that category.
Although there might not be many changes to that particular category listing. In essences it also mains that that icon list (as its a manual listing) would need to be updated with any category-list change, which kinda defeats to purpose of a category page (setup/create and forget).
Even if it that icon-list was automated, it still is not really useful as such in a category page.
Please find some alternative solution/location for that list.
.MvGulik. 18:45, 30 July 2021 (UTC)

While I agree that having the list automated would be a much better option, I disagree that it doesn't add anything. I feel like many users, who don't speak english all that well, would appreciate having the magics listed with their icons to easily look them up in the game. I realise that most users would look for a ::specific magic by its name but I think that having them listed (at least somewhere, not necessarily on the category page) would be helpful to some people. Especially since I removed the table containing all of them from Hearth Magic.

.Malyglut. 12:10, 31 July 2021 (UTC)

>"I think that having them listed (at least somewhere, not necessarily on the category page) would be helpful"

I kinda already agreed with that part. With the note the category page is the least favorite option/location for this. .MvGulik. 10:46, 31 July 2021 (UTC)

Alright, I must have misunderstood your initial message then, in that case I will create a separate page for a list of Hearth Magic abilities and add a link to it from the Category page.

.Malyglut. 13:44, 1 August 2021 (UTC)